Re: Unix * weirdness

[BlueBoar () THIEVCO COM (Blue Boar)]

> The problem here is that you've got the wrong model of the Unix universe.
> Quoting [any way: \, ", '] and wildcards are functions of the *SHELL* and
> all do their thing _before_ the called-program is run.  By the time the
> called-program is run *all* of that stuff is gone and the program just
> gets plain-jane 'strings' as its arguments.  The 'quotes' and such are
> **NOT** passed on... they're jsut directvies _to_hte_shell_ on how to
> massage the strings on the command line before passing them to the called
> program.

Yup. My light bulb finally lit with Warner's last message.  I used to
know this at one point in time, I've written argv parsing code
before.  Of course, I selectively forget in front of 3000+
subscribers.:)

The - is special to rm, not the shell.  & | et all are special
to the shell, not rm.  But the shell doesn't use them as part
of * expansion, so neither one cares.

> > How about if there's a space in front?
>
> Doesn't matter.  Again, you need to have the right model: when the shell
> expands wildcards, it "plugs in" the expansion strings
> *no*matter*what*they*are*, and drops the resuling string as an argument
> to the called program.

Right.  I tried it, because I was still curious.. I
created /tmp/ -stay

Since - isn't the first character in that parameter, the - doesn't
help and rm eats is just fine.  As others have noted /tmp/-stay
gets deleted fine for the same reason.  I'm now convinced
there's no fun to be had with the rm -rf /tmp/* script.

                                        BB