nanog mailing list archives

Re: Clueless service restrictions (was RE: Anti-spam System Idea)


From: Randy Bush <randy () psg com>
Date: Tue, 17 Feb 2004 13:05:02 -0800


The Internet has value because it allows arbitrary interactions where new
applications can be developed and fostered. The centrally controlled model
would have prevented IM, web, sip applications, etc. from ever being
deployed. If there are any operators out there who still understand the
value in allowing the next generation of applications to incubate, you need
to push back on this tendency to limit the Internet to an 'approved' list of
ports and service models.

bingo!

and, if you want to see a particularly broken example, buy
"internet service" from t-mobile gprs in the states, port
22 blocked, no smtp relay, ...  "walled garden" mentality
from the get go.

randy


Current thread: